Mindfulness May Have Negative Impact on Memories
the Psychiatry Advisor take:
While mindfulness has been praised for benefits to several psychiatric disorders including depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder, the mediation might have a downside: It may make memories less accurate.
Brent M. Wilson, a PhD candidate at the University of California, San Diego, and colleagues wanted to find out whether mindfulness might lead to uncertainty regarding the source of a memory.
The researchers enrolled 153 participants in two experiments. They were divided into two groups: mindfulness and mind-wandering. In the first experiment, the mindfulness cohort was asked to focus on breathing without judgment, while the other cohort was told to think about whatever came to mind.
In the second experiment, the participants were then asked to study and then recall a list of words related to trash, though the list did not include the actual word.
While 39% of the mindfulness participants incorrectly recalled seeing the word “trash” on the list, only 20% of the mind-wandering participants did, the researchers reported in the journal Psychological Science.
“When memories of imagined and real experiences too closely resemble each other, people can have difficulty determining which is which, and this can lead to falsely remembering imagined experiences as actual experiences,” Wilson said in a statement.
Participants who had done mindfulness meditation just prior to a memory recall task did worse than those who let their minds wander.
Mindfulness meditation is associated with all sorts of benefits to mental and physical well-being, but a new study suggests that it may also come with a particular downside for memory. The findings, published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, show that participants who engaged in a 15-minute mindfulness meditation session were less able to differentiate items they actually encountered from items they only imagined.
Researchers wondered whether the very mechanism that seems to underlie the benefits of mindfulness — judgment-free thoughts and feelings — might also affect people's ability to determine the origin of a given memory. Some memories originate from an external source, such as an actual experience of eating an omelet for breakfast. But other memories originate from an internal source, such as imagining the experience of eating an omelet for breakfast.
Sign Up for Free e-newsletters
Psychiatry Advisor Articles
- Triiodothyronine in the Treatment of Bipolar Depression
- Antidepressants Increase Seizure Risk in Youth and Severely Depressed
- Intranasal Oxytocin Reduces Negative Effects, Improves Cognitive Function in Schizophrenia
- E-Cigarettes Associated With More Harms Than Benefits at Population Level
- Examining Rates of Long-Term Opioid Use in Youth With Psychiatric Disorders
- Suicide-Screening Toolkit Can Help Identify Youths at High Risk for Suicide
- Researchers Identify Novel Potential Biomarkers for Autism
- Agoraphobia: An Evolving Understanding of Definitions and Treatment
- Parental Pressure to Diet Linked With Long-term Harm in Adolescents
- Does Access to Medical Cannabis Reduce Risk for Opioid Abuse?
- Supported Employment vs Transitional Work in Veterans With PTSD
- Comparing Pharmacologic Treatments for Prevention of Rehospitalization in BP
- Preliminary Evidence Suggests Suicidal Thinking Is Self-Reinforcing
- Lower Fluoxetine Efficacy in Elderly Patients With Major Depressive Disorder
- Personal Health Information Found in Recycling